pytorch

9e3605de - [RELAND] New operator registration API (#35061) (#35629)

[RELAND] New operator registration API (#35061) (#35629) Summary: Reland of https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch/pull/35061 ; removed the get qualified type name magic from debug strings to work around MSVC 2017 bug. Main points of the new API: - You can register implementations (impl) without having to specify a schema. - Registrations are commutative, so no matter what order your static initializers run, you end up with the same end result. op_registration_test.cpp contains a reasonably comprehensive accounting for the available API surface How does this implementation proceed? The basic concept is to relax the internal invariants of Dispatcher data structures to allow the possibility that a FunctionSchema is not specified in an Operator. - DispatchKeyExtractor has an uninitialized state where it doesn't look for dispatch keys in any arguments of the stack. It can have a schema (de)registered to itself post facto with registerSchema/unregisterSchema. - DispatchTable has a new constructor taking only an OperatorName for the uninitialized state. It can have a schema (de)registered to itself post facto with registerSchema/unregisterSchema - OperatorDef maintains counts of both defs and well as defs_and_impls. defs_and_impls keeps track of the outstanding impl registrations; you may have impl registrations but no defs. If there are no defs (no schema), the operator is not returned by findSchema. A new findOperatorByName fucntion unconditionally returns the OperatorHandle even if there's no schema. OperatorHandle::hasSchema can be used to check if the operator has schema. - Replaced 'registerKernel' with 'registerImpl', which is the new interface for directly registering kernels without implementations. - Because 'registerImpl' no longer requires an OperatorHandle, change 'registerDef' to only return a RegistrationHandleRAII. This is marginally less efficient (since we're doing two hash table lookups on a registration now), but this won't matter in the long term, and probably doesn't matter now either. - Rename registerBackendFallbackKernel to registerFallback (this exposed a bunch of places where we're improperly directly interfacing with Dispatcher; we need to add this capability to the true public API) - All code generated internal registrations are switched to use the new API. This includes VariableType registrations (which previously weren't converted) and the mobile autograd stuff - Switch the new-style def()/impl() APIs to interact directly with Dispatcher, rather than indirecting through the old API - We deleted alias analysis kind merging entirely. As a nod to BC, it's possible to define a full schema with alias analysis kind, and then later do another full schema def with missing alias analysis kind, but the opposite direction is not allowed. We can remove this entirely following the plan at https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch/issues/35040 - Schema matching is moved inside the dispatcher, because we might not be able to immediately schema match at the point of an impl() (because we don't have the schema yet). To do this, we store the inferred function schema inside a KernelEntry, so we can check it when we get the real schema. - Registered kernel functions now store a debug string which can be used to more easily identify them. Tests use this to distinguish between multiple distinct registrations; regular invocations get only very basic information. Because we need our static initializers to work no matter what order they're run, the testing strategy on this PR is quite involved. The general concept: - Bind a (very gimped) version of the dispatcher API from Python, so that we can easily write a more complex testing harness using expect tests. - For series of registrations we want to test, exhaustively test every possible permutation of registrations (and deregistrations), and show that the intermediate states agree no matter what path is taken. - Intermediate states are rendered using a new dumpState() debugging method that prints the internal state of the dispatcher. This method may be generally useful for people who want to see what's in the dispatcher. - Simultaneously, add a new invariant testing function which checks that the internal invariants of the dispatcher are upheld (so we don't have to print internal implementation details of the dispatcher) The testing framework found a few bugs in development. For example, here is a case where we registered schema too early, before checking if it was valid: ``` Traceback (most recent call last): File "test/test_dispatch.py", line 164, in test_def_impl_schema_mismatch ], raises=True) File "test/test_dispatch.py", line 135, in commute results=results, raises=raises) File "test/test_dispatch.py", line 83, in run_permutation .format(ctor_order[:i], op_ix)) File "test/test_dispatch.py", line 59, in check_invariants .format(expected_provenance, actual_provenance) AssertionError: 'name[16 chars]ema: (none)\ncatchall: boxed unboxed :: (Tenso[18 chars]0)\n' != 'name[16 chars]ema: test::foo(Tensor x, Tensor y) -> (Tensor)[53 chars]0)\n' name: test::foo - schema: (none) + schema: test::foo(Tensor x, Tensor y) -> (Tensor) catchall: boxed unboxed :: (Tensor _0) -> (Tensor _0) : expected from running ctors (1,); actual from running ctors (1,) and then failing to run ctor 0 (did this failure leave the dispatcher in a wedged state? it shouldn't!) ``` There are also C++ smoketests for the API. These tests comprehensively cover the C++ API surface of the new operator registration API, but don't check very hard if the API does the right thing (that's what test_dispatch.py is for) Some miscellaneous changes which could have been split into other PRs, but I was too lazy to do so: - Add torch::jit::parseName (mirroring parseSchema/parseSchemaOrName) - Add cloneWithName functionality to FunctionSchema - Unconditionally generate schema registration, even when type_method_dispatch is a dict. The one exception is for manual registrations.... - Add fallback, CppFunction::makeFallthrough and CppFunction::makeFromBoxedFunction to public API of op_registration, so we can stop calling internal registerImpl directly - Add new syntax sugar dispatch_autograd for registering autograd kernels - Minor OperatorName cleanup, storing OperatorName in DispatchTable and defining operator<< on OperatorName - Refactored the op registration API to take FunctionSchema directly. We now do namespacing by post facto fixing up the OperatorName embedded in FunctionSchema. This also means that you can now do torch::import("ns1").def("ns2::blah") and have the ns2 override ns1 (although maybe this is not the correct behavior.) - New torch::schema public API, for attaching alias analysis kind annotation kinds. This meant we had to template up some function signatures which previously took const char*. There's now a nice comment explaining this strategy. - torch::import now takes std::string which means we can use the namespacing from Python Signed-off-by: Edward Z. Yang <ezyang@fb.com> Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch/pull/35629 Differential Revision: D20724551 Pulled By: ezyang fbshipit-source-id: befa46a1affb4ec4ae1fb39e3564a63695a6ca41