PR #4291 MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event

MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event #4291

turt2live merged 8 commits into main from matthew/msc4291

msc4291 placeholder

c4ec5567

turt2live added proposal

turt2live added needs-implementation

turt2live marked this pull request as draft 1 year ago

turt2live added proposal-placeholder

turt2live removed proposal

turt2live added action-required

Add MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event

81cfe197

tulir changed the title ~~[WIP] Placeholder~~ MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event 1 year ago

tulir marked this pull request as ready for review 1 year ago

Fix image src

b2f4c9c2

tulir removed needs-implementation

tulir removed proposal-placeholder

tulir removed action-required

tulir added requires-room-version

tulir added proposal

tulir added A-Federation

tulir added A-Room Spec

tulir added unassigned-room-version

tulir added kind:maintenance

turt2live added M-maybe next room version?

turt2live commented on 2025-07-10

turt2live added needs-implementation

turt2live commented on 2025-07-10

TheArcaneBrony commented on 2025-07-10

Gnuxie commented on 2025-07-10

mscbot added proposed-final-comment-period

mscbot added disposition-merge

mscbot added unresolved-concerns

turt2live removed kind:maintenance

turt2live added kind:core

Gnuxie commented on 2025-07-11

jevolk commented on 2025-07-14

jevolk requested changes on 2025-07-14

Review comments

4abea871

Add prose on blocking alternative

0a7e97fd

Gnuxie commented on 2025-07-15

kegsay commented on 2025-07-15

Add MSC4311 note

60a3b7d7

anoadragon453 approved these changes on 2025-07-15

Update proposals/4291-room-ids-as-hashes.md

cafeaa6a

mscbot removed unresolved-concerns

mscbot removed proposed-final-comment-period

mscbot added final-comment-period

turt2live removed needs-implementation

HarHarLinks commented on 2025-07-17

jevolk approved these changes on 2025-07-17

FSG-Cat commented on 2025-07-17

mscbot removed disposition-merge

mscbot removed final-comment-period

mscbot added finished-final-comment-period

turt2live removed finished-final-comment-period

turt2live added final-comment-period

Half-Shot commented on 2025-07-22

11th hour review

c0dd8d22

turt2live removed final-comment-period

turt2live added finished-final-comment-period

turt2live merged b1f4ea8c into main 1 year ago

turt2live removed finished-final-comment-period

turt2live added spec-pr-missing

turt2live assigned

turt2live 1 year ago

turt2live removed spec-pr-missing

turt2live removed unassigned-room-version

turt2live added spec-pr-in-review

turt2live removed spec-pr-in-review

turt2live added merged

tulir removed M-maybe next room version?

Reviewers

anoadragon453

jevolk

turt2live

tulir

Half-Shot

kegsay

KitsuneRal

CobaltCause

FSG-Cat

HarHarLinks

TheArcaneBrony

JadedBlueEyes

Gnuxie

zecakeh

spaetz

Assignees

turt2live

Labels

requires-room-version merged proposal A-Federation A-Room Spec kind:core

Milestone

No milestone

matrix-spec-proposals MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event #4291 Merged

MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event #4291

matrix-spec-proposals
MSC4291: Room IDs as hashes of the create event
#4291

Merged